The Appeal Court on Monday, reserved judgement to decide on the case by Senator Ademola Adeleke challenging the decision of an election petition tribunal which nullified his victory in the Osun governorship election.
Judgement on the matter will be given at a later date as a three-member panel led by Justice Mohammed Shuaibu takes the arguments and adopts the briefs of all parties in the suit.
During proceedings today, Counsel to Adeleke, Onyechi Ikpeazu, held that a member of the panel, who is also a chief magistrate, did not air her opinion during the Judgement delivery. Rather, she only appended her signature and the constitution mandates her to have aired her views about the suit.
Counsel to Mr Oyetola, Lateef Fagbemi, however, held that mere signing of the judgment, and not making any comment afterwards does not make the judgment invalid.
He noted that the case of over voting exceeded 6 polling units as claimed by the Appellant, adding that the anomaly was experienced in 744 polling units across the state.
Fagbemi further stressed that the findings of over voting were obtained from the back end server of INEC.
In their defense however, Onyechi Ikpeazu held that results stored in the backend server, are inconsistent and unreliable as they can be affected by internet connectivity and battery life of the Bvas used to upload the result.
These two factors according to him can affect the upload.
Adelekeโs counsel also stated that he conducted a physical examination on the Bvas, and it showed that over voting occurred in just six polling units, and not 744 as claimed by the Counsel to Oyetola
Senator Adeleke who is candidate of the Peopleโs Democratic Party had won the said election held on 16 July, 2022, the result which was nullified on the grounds of over-voting.
Adeleke had in February, appealed the judgement of the Osun State Governorship Tribunal which nullified his election.
The tribunal ruled in favour of a former governor of the state Gboyega Oyetola. While delivering the judgement, two out of the three-member panel of the tribunal held that Oyetola proved that there was over-voting in some of the polling units.
But Adeleke swiftly rejected the ruling and described it as a โmiscarriage of justiceโ. Weeks later, the governor filed an appeal before the Akure division of the Court of Appeal.
In the 31 grounds of appeal filed on Wednesday, Adeleke prayed the court for โan order setting aside the whole decision of the tribunalโ.
The governor equally sought โan order striking out the petition for want of competence and jurisdiction or in the alternative, an order dismissing the petition on the meritโ.
โThe second respondent cannot โgo lo lo lo loโ and โbuga wonโ as the duly elected governor of Osun state,โ the governor said.
โThe tribunal, in its judgment, erred in law and displayed bias against the appellant when it made reference to the appellantโs dance at his inauguration as governor of Osun state which was never an issue before the lower tribunal,โ Adeleke noted.
โBy referring to the appellantโs personal eccentricity for dancing, the lower tribunal derided and mocked him in a manner suggesting that it was biased against him.
โThe appearance of bias manifests in the reference to the Appellantโs proclivity for dancing and particularly the Buga song, has rendered the decision of the lower Tribunal a nullity.
โThe tribunal in its judgment erred in law in returning the 1st respondent as the duly elected candidate without due regard to the enormity of the voters in the units where the results were cancelled for overvoting.โ
