The
run on British property funds has drawn attention to the vulnerability
of the commercial real estate sector, largely funded by domestic banks
and building societies but increasingly by foreign banks and insurers.
U.K.
banks and building societies had around 90 billion pounds ($117
billion) in credit extended to domestic commercial real estate at the
end of 2015, according to a study by De Montfort University.
German,
other international and U.S. banks had 55 billion pounds of exposure,
having increased their investments in the sector since the 2008
financial crisis. Insurers, which prior to the crisis had barely any
exposure accounted for 25.9 billion.
This means they could all take a hit if Britain’s vote to leave the European Union leads to a slowdown in business investment and depresses demand for offices and shopping centers, as expected.
“There is a lot of uncertainty at the moment,” said Sonja Knorr, a funds analyst in Germany at rating agency Scope.
“Transactions in the U.K. have come to a halt.”
The
total value of UK outstanding commercial real estate debt, stood at
183.3 billion pounds as at Dec. 31 2015, the De Montfort study said.
The
uncertainty has already caused panic among some commercial property
investors. In the past week, more than 18 billion pounds of investor
cash in commercial property has been frozen as funds run by M&G
Investments, Standard Life Investments and Threadneedle Investments,
among others, suspended trading.
Price drop likely
While
ordinary retail investors stand to lose most initially, some funds have
been paring back the value they put on their property – a signal that a
price drop is likely. That would hit the banks that lent or insurers
invested in property.
Legal & General’s fund arm and F&C
Investments both cut the value of their UK property funds on Thursday to
discourage withdrawals.
“Property is so much about confidence,”
said Danny Cox of broker Hargreaves Lansdown. “Once you have this kind
of dent, it will take a time to come back.”
While U.K. banks’
exposure to the sector is high, accounting for 45 percent of lending
last year, according to the De Montfort Commercial Property Lending
Report, it is down from over two thirds a decade ago. U.K. banks’ loans
to the sector have declined every year since 2009, says Bernstein
Research, only returning to slight growth in March this year.
Meanwhile, German
banks had more than 18 billion pounds of outstanding loans in British
real estate compared to 10.5 billion of U.S. peers at the end of last
year, De Montfort said. For some foreign lenders, commercial property
may still be attractive proposition because of the fall in the value of
the pound.
“A 17 percent fall in the value of sterling makes
investments in Britain interesting, despite the Brexit. That goes for UK
property as well, an area we are now looking at,” said Andreas Gruber,
chief investment officer of German insurer Allianz, responsible for investments of 640 billion euros.
“The lower value of the currency offers an attractive discount.”